The European Commission put a Matrix client on every staff laptop by September 2026. That's more than 40,000 people on Element and Synapse, rolled out in nine months. If you're looking for a self-hosted Slack alternative and your team keeps saying "Matrix won't scale" or "nobody will use it", those two objections just got a lot weaker.
They didn't go away entirely, though. The Commission's rollout broke in a few places, and those places are where a small team will get hurt too. So here's what went wrong at 40k seats, then which Matrix server to pick, how to get your Slack history over, and what it costs a team of 10 to 100 people.
How the European Commission rolled out Matrix
The timeline, from Element's write-up (as rewritten by LavX) and Computerworld's coverage:
- Summer 2025: project starts. December 2025: proof of concept done.
- January to June 2026: production infrastructure, hosting and operations.
- Pilots on laptops, then a mobile pilot through their MDM.
- July to September 2026: laptop client pushed to everyone, in waves.
The stack is Element Server Suite Pro running several Synapse homeservers. The hosting comes from sovereign cloud providers picked by tender, and the Commission operates the service itself. Login goes through EU Login, the SSO staff already use every day.
That's nine months from PoC to 40,000 seats. And it isn't the biggest Matrix deployment in Europe: Computerworld notes France's Tchap is used by "more than 400,000 civil servants each month".
Where the rollout hurt (and where it'll hurt you)
Neither the Element write-up nor Computerworld reports trouble with the EU Login integration. The pain was elsewhere.
Finding people
Early users on different Synapse servers "could not always find one another", and the Commission's team had to work with Element to fix cross-server user search. Accounts were also self-created rather than pre-provisioned, so anyone who hadn't signed in yet simply didn't exist in search. A small team runs one server, so you skip the first problem. The second one still applies: pre-create accounts or bulk-invite everyone on day one.
Presence
Online/away status was turned off because it was dragging down performance as more people onboarded. The team is working with Element on a user-status feature to replace it. Presence has a reputation as one of Synapse's most expensive features. At 30 users you can probably leave it on. Turn it off the moment your homeserver starts sweating.
Mobile
Desktop is done. A mobile pilot ran, but Computerworld still describes the full mobile rollout as "planned", which tells you something about how hard push notifications are to get right. The HN thread is full of it: one commenter reports battery drain "like 70% compared to other apps" on budget Android phones without Google push, and another says Element X on Android notifies them for every message even while they're active on desktop, a bug tracked in an element-meta issue opened in 2015.
Expectations
Computerworld says it isn't meant as a direct replacement for Teams at this stage. Diana Gheorghe, head of sector for Communication and Collaboration Services, said it will "complement" the existing workplace apps and that "there's no 'one-to-one' parity". Politico reported on staff reactions comparing it unfavourably to Teams.
So yes, part of the "scale" argument holds up. The Commission runs Matrix as a secure second channel next to Teams. It isn't the one chat tool for all 40,000 people. I don't think that matters much for your team, which is more likely 40 engineers and a bot that posts CI failures than a political institution with 40,000 Teams users.
Which Matrix server: Synapse vs Tuwunel vs Conduit
For a small team, this is the decision you'll actually have to make.
| | Synapse | Tuwunel | Continuwuity | Conduit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Latest (Nov 2026) | v1.165.0 | v2.0.0 | v26.9.4 | v0.10.17 |
| Language | Python + Rust | Rust | Rust | Rust |
| License | AGPL-3.0 or commercial | Apache-2.0 | Apache-2.0 | Apache-2.0 |
| Database | PostgreSQL | RocksDB | RocksDB | RocksDB |
| OIDC / MAS | Yes (via MAS) | Yes (native, opt-in) | not listed on areweoidcyet | No |
| Migrate from Synapse | n/a | "Not yet, but this is planned" | No | - |
Sources: Synapse releases, Tuwunel, Continuwuity, areweoidcyet.com.
If you want SSO, bridges, or Element's admin tools, pick Synapse with Postgres. It's the reference server, its OIDC support goes through Matrix Authentication Service, and the Synapse docs say plainly that "SQLite should not be used in a production server." It's heavy, though. In the HN thread, Element CEO Matthew Hodgson (Arathorn) admitted Synapse "has historically been particularly clunky" and said a fork shown at the Matrix Conference "improved CPU 10x" by moving the hot path to Rust. Those gains haven't landed in a release yet.
If you want a small box and you're starting from scratch, pick Tuwunel. It calls itself the official successor to conduwuit, the Swiss government is its main sponsor, and it has native OIDC login (off by default; set native_auth = true under [global.authentication.oidc]). The catch is migration: there's no path from Synapse yet, and nothing documented for going the other way either. Whatever you set up on Tuwunel, plan on staying there.
I'd skip plain Conduit for a team server. areweoidcyet.com lists it as not supporting OIDC, and one HN commenter said it broke some rooms they shared with Synapse users (they thought Synapse deviates from the spec, but the rooms broke either way).
The fastest install: ESS Community on Kubernetes
Element ships a free Helm chart, ess-helm. It bundles Synapse, MAS, Element Web, Element Admin, Element Call's RTC backend, Hookshot (for GitHub/GitLab/webhook bots), and an optional PostgreSQL. Minimum spec: "at least 2 CPU cores and 2 GB of memory", on K3s or any other Kubernetes.
Read the fine print before you build on it. The chart targets "non-commercial community use cases with up to 100 users". The pricing page describes the Community homeserver as "not for use in production environments", and the Enterprise plan that includes ESS Pro shows no prices, only "Priced per seat/month" from 100 users. If you're a company, ESS Community is fine for an evaluation. For production, either budget for Enterprise or run upstream Synapse yourself using the official image:
docker pull ghcr.io/element-hq/synapse:v1.165.0If you don't want Kubernetes, the matrix-docker-ansible-deploy playbook linked from the Synapse docs is what most self-hosters I know actually use.
Migrating from Slack: bridge or import
You have two options, and neither is great.
What I'd do: export Slack, archive the JSON somewhere searchable, bridge the five channels people actually use, and stop worrying about the rest. Nobody is going to scroll back to 2021.
What leaving Slack actually costs
- One more service to keep patched. mautrix-slack v0.2609.1 was a security release, Continuwuity v26.9.4 says "Update as soon as possible", and Synapse ships a stable release about every two weeks.
- E2EE key verification. People will see "Unable to decrypt" at least once. The Commission documented device verification and account recovery for staff. Do the same, one page is enough.
- Mobile notifications, especially on Android phones without Google services.
- The gap in integrations. Hookshot covers GitHub, GitLab and webhooks. Your Salesforce-to-Slack workflow is gone.
If Matrix isn't the right fit, ExitPath catalogues open-source exits from Slack, Notion and Microsoft 365 (Zulip and Mattermost for chat, Outline and AppFlowy for Notion, though one commenter points out Outline isn't open source). Use it as a starting point, and read the HN thread too, because commenters argue with several of its picks. Zulip gets a lot of praise there, and someone warns that Mattermost's licence change made GitLab login unavailable for small companies.
So what's your excuse now?
"It won't scale" doesn't hold up after this rollout. "Users won't accept it" is shakier, judging by the staff reactions Politico reported. On the teams I've worked with, what actually kept people on Slack was one Jira integration and a VP who likes the huddle button.
What's actually keeping your team on Slack or Teams: integrations, habit, or management? And if you tried Matrix and went back, tell me which thing broke first.
Sources
- How the European Commission rolled out Matrix to more than 40,000 staff (Element blog) and HN discussion
- LavX summary of the Element post
- Computerworld: Matrix gains ground in Europe's public sector
- Synapse, ess-helm, Element pricing
- Tuwunel, Continuwuity, areweoidcyet.com
- mautrix-slack, slack-matrix-migration
- ExitPath and HN discussion
